The Census Bureau released its annual report yesterday on “Income and Poverty in the United States: 2019” with lots of updated data on household income and household demographics. Based on those new data, I present my annual post titled “Explaining US Income Inequality by Household Demographics.”
Most of the discussion on income inequality focuses on the relative
differences over time between low-income and high-income American
households. But it’s also informative to analyze the demographic
differences among income groups at a given point in time to answer
- How are high-income households different demographically from
low-income households that would help us better understand income
- For low-income households today who aspire to become
higher-income households in the future, what lifestyle and demographic
changes might facilitate the path to a higher income?
The chart above (click to enlarge) shows some key demographic characteristics of US households by income quintiles (five equal groups of 25,690 US households) for 2019, using Census Bureau data available here and here. Below is a summary of some of the key demographic differences between American households in different income quintiles in 2019:
1. Mean Number of Earners per Household. On average, there are four times more income earners per household in the top income quintile households (2.0) than earners per household in the lowest-income households (0.50). Also note that the average number of earners per household increases for each higher income quintile, demonstrating that one of the main factors in explaining differences in income among US households is the number of earners per household. Also, the unadjusted ratio of average income for the highest to the lowest quintile of 16.6-to-1 ($254,449 to $15,286) falls to a ratio of only 4.2-to-1 when comparing “income per earner” between those two quintiles: $127,225 for the top quintile to $30,572 for the bottom quintile.
2. Share of Households with No Earners. More than six out of every ten American households (60.8%) in the bottom fifth of households by income had no earners in 2019. In contrast, only 5.0% of the households in the top fifth had no earners last year, providing more evidence of the strong relationship between average household income and income earners per household.
3. Marital Status of Householders. Married-couple households represent a much greater share of the top income quintile (77.9%) than for the bottom income quintile (16.0%), and single-parent or single households represented a much greater share of the bottom one-fifth of households (84.0%) than for the top one-fifth (22.1%). Consistent with the pattern for the average number of earners per household, the share of married-couple households also increases for each higher income quintile, from 16.0% (lowest quintile) to 35.1% (second lowest quintile) to 49.4% (middle quintile) to 64.2% (second highest quintile) to 77.9% (highest quintile).
4. Age of Householders. Nearly 7 out of every 10 US households (69.4%) in the top income quintile included Americans in their prime earning years between the ages of 35-64, compared to fewer than half (40.4%) of households in the bottom income quintile who had householders in that prime earning age group last year. The share of householders in the prime earning age group of 35-64 year-olds increases with each higher income quintile, from 40.2% (lowest quintile) to 43.9% to 50.3% (middle quintile) to 59.7% to 69.4% (highest quintile).
Compared to members of the top income quintile of American households by income, household members in the bottom income quintile were more likely (18.5% for the lowest quintile vs. 13.9% for the highest quintile) to be in the youngest age group (under 35 years), and 2.5 times more likely (41.3% vs. 16.7%) to be in the oldest age group (65 years and over).
By average age, Americans in the highest three income groups are the youngest (about 50 years on average) and the lowest income group is the oldest quintile on average at 56.9 years.
5. Work Status of Householders. Nearly four times (3.8) as many top quintile households included at least one adult who was working full-time in 2019 (77.8%) compared to the bottom income quintile (only 20.6%), and nearly five times as many households in the bottom quintile included adults who did not work at all (66.4%) compared to top quintile households whose family members did not work (13.8%). The share of households having one or more full-time worker increases at each higher income quintile (20.6% to 48.9% to 62.0% to 72.0% to 77.8%).
6. Education of householders. Family members of households in the top fifth of US households by income were four times more likely to have a college degree (68.6%) than members of households in the bottom income quintile (only 17.1%). In contrast, householders in the lowest income quintile were 13 times more likely than those in the top income quintile to have less than a high school degree in 2019 (19.6% vs. 1.5%). As expected, the Census data show that there is a significantly positive relationship between average educational attainment and average household income.
Summary: Household demographics, including the average number of earners per household and the marital status, age, and education of householders are all very highly correlated with American’s household income. Specifically, high-income US households have more income-earners on average than lower-income households, and individuals in high-income households are far more likely on average than individuals in low-income households to be well-educated, married, working full-time, and in their prime earning years. In contrast, individuals in lower-income US households are far more likely than Americans in higher-income households to be less-educated, working part-time, either very young (under 35 years) or very old (over 65 years), and living in single-parent or single-member households.
The good news about the Census Bureau is that the key demographic factors that explain differences in household income are not fixed over our lifetimes and are largely under our control (e.g., staying in school and graduating from high school and college, getting and staying married, working full-time, etc.), which means that individuals and households are not destined to remain in a single-member, low-income quintile forever. Fortunately, studies that track people over time find evidence of significant income mobility in America confirming that individuals and households move up and down the income quintiles over their lifetimes, as the key demographic variables highlighted above change, see related CD posts here, here and here. Those links highlight the research of social scientists Thomas Hirschl (Cornell) and Mark Rank (Washington University) showing that as a result of dynamic income mobility nearly 70% of Americans will be in the top income quintile for at least one year while almost one-third will be in the top quintile for ten years or more (see chart below).
As Thomas Sowell pointed out in his syndicated column in March 2013 “Economic Mobility”:
Most working Americans who were initially in the bottom 20% of income-earners, rise out of that bottom 20%. More of them end up in the top 20% than remain in the bottom 20%. People who were initially in the bottom 20% in income have had the highest rate of increase in their incomes, while those who were initially in the top 20% have had the lowest. This is the direct opposite of the pattern found when following income brackets over time, rather than following individual people.
MP: It’s highly likely that most of today’s high-income, college-educated, married Americans who are now in their peak earning years were in a lower-income quintile in their prior younger years when they were single and before they acquired education and job experience. It’s also likely that individuals in today’s top income quintiles will move back down to a lower-income quintile in the future during their retirement years, which is just part of the natural dynamic lifetime cycle of moving up and down the income quintiles for a majority of Americans. So when the incessant chatter from the mainstream media and progressive politicians about an “income inequality crisis” in America, we should keep in mind that basic household demographics go a long way towards explaining the differences in household income in the United States. And because the key income-determining demographic variables are largely under our control and change dynamically over our lifetimes, income mobility and the American dream are still “alive and well” in the US.